Madewell vs Everlane
As a lover of Madewell’s Whisper Cotton V-Neck Pocket Tee (I own 2 and considering a 3rd), I decided to try the muscle version when I was in the store recently. And I was a huge fan. I tried on the XS and it was perfect. This muscle tank is cotton and soft, but definitely a slub cotton more then your standard straight cotton. It fits nicely, lays well on the body and washes well. So, it’s pretty much perfect. 😊 (There’s also the navy striped version, too, which I like).
This tank is so much softer then you’d expect. If you saw my recent post with my latest Everlane review, you may know I originally got this tank in pink last summer in the XS. I kept it and wore it and my only issue was that it was a little high up in the armpits. So, not ideal but not enough to return it. I also think I couldn’t decide which size to go with and didn’t feel like bothering to exchange it for the small or the small wasn’t available. In any case, that’s why when I decided to get it in white, I sized up to the small. It fit so well! The length wasn’t too bad for my short waist either, which was one concern I had about sizing up.
Honestly, there was no clear winner. I literally like them both! Besides, the price, fit, and fabric, I just can’t see an issue with one being a clear winner over the other. And I’m not sure having too many white tanks is ever an issue. So for now, they’re both staying in my closet. 😊